Turning Houses into Homes, one address at a time! Serving the greater Indianapolis area!

23 S Butler Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46219

Square Feet 3 Bedrooms 1 Full 1 Half Baths

Property Description

This historic Irvington home is a stunningly modern Queen Anne Victorian with unique barrel, transom, and diamond windows. Seller spent well over 1,000 hours & $120k+ making this home a beautiful example of its era--carefully blending historical beauty with modern convenience. Original hardwoods professionally refinished downstairs, all new carpet upstairs. The Kitchen & baths were all completely remodeled. Kitchen now opens up to a huge island with breakfast bars, granite counters, new SS appliances, all new cabinets, and a waterproof LVT floor. Full bath now has a tiled modern walk-in shower with daylight side panel, a separate soaking tub, and double vanity. Renovations photo-documented with fun finds along the way. An absolute MUST SEE!

Quick Summary

MLS Number 21678029
Price $275,000
Lot Size 0.118 Acres
Bedrooms 3
Bathrooms 1 Full 1 Half
Basement No
School District Indianapolis Public Schools
Status Closed
Year Built 1896
Garages No
Fireplaces 0
List Date 10/25/2019
Township Warren

Property Map


From Emerson and E.Washington St, head East on Washington in right lane. Turn Right just after the Butler Inn onto Butler Avenue (ONE WAY SOUTH). Parking allowed in lot on the East side just North of the alley.

What's the Payment?

Loan Amount* ($):

Loan Rate* (%):

Loan Term* (Years):

Home Value* ($)

Annual Taxes* ($):

Annual Insurance* ($):

Annual PMI* (%):


Projected Amounts:

Contact Us!

Nathan Pfahler

Nathan Pfahler

Phone: (317) 352-5994
Mobile: (317) 450-1094
Email Adress: npfahler@gmail.com

Listing provided courtesy of Coldwell Banker - Kaiser

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Ā© 2021 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORSĀ®