Turning Houses into Homes, one address at a time! Serving the greater Indianapolis area!

4442 S Cemetery Road
Shelbyville, IN 46176

Square Feet 3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths

Property Description

If only these walls could talk! Close your eyes and imagine school children entering thru these doors to learn about life in a simpler time and place. This 3 BR 2 BA home was a 2 room brick school and has been tastefully converted while maintaining its historical integrity. Exterior walls are 3 bricks thick allowing for 12 inch deep windowsills, features 1993 sq ft of living space and a custom steel and copper staircase. The open floor plan includes a massive 2 story Great Room with Gas fireplace, dining, kitchen and cathedral ceilings that highlight an original truss. A 3 car garage provides parking and storage. Welcome to the country here the sunsets overlooking McCrea's and McFerrin's Mountains are amazing.

Quick Summary

MLS Number 21651986
Price $274,900
Lot Size 0.89 Acres
Bedrooms 3
Bathrooms Full
Basement No
School District Southwestern Shelby County Consolidated Schools
Status Closed
Year Built 1880
Garages Yes
List Date 07/01/2019
Township Hendricks

Property Map


From W St Rd 44/McKay Rd, drive S on Smithland Rd approx 4 miles, turn Rt at the Smithland intersection then a hard Rt on Cemetery, home is on the Rt, sign in yard.

What's the Payment?

Loan Amount* ($):

Loan Rate* (%):

Loan Term* (Years):

Home Value* ($)

Annual Taxes* ($):

Annual Insurance* ($):

Annual PMI* (%):


Projected Amounts:

Contact Us!

Nathan Pfahler

Nathan Pfahler

Phone: (317) 352-5994
Mobile: (317) 450-1094
Email Adress: npfahler@gmail.com

Listing provided courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2021 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®