Turning Houses into Homes, one address at a time! Serving the greater Indianapolis area!

5163 E Wenz Drive
Monticello, IN 47960

Square Feet 5 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths

Property Description

Initially constructed in 1940 along the sought after Isle of Homes on beautiful Lake Shafer, this extraordinary estate underwent an extensive renovation in 2006-2009. The gourmet kitchen was the centerpiece of this remastering with its 1000 lb limestone hood, Fisher & Pykel gas range and oven, and carved marble farm sink. The floors are a stunning mix of travertine, original hardwoods, and new hardwoods. The waterfront property features 98 feet of shoreline and is easily enjoyed via the large patio with ample entertaining space and hot tub with water accessed via private dock with electric covered boat lift. The rolling acreage boasts woods with golf cart trails and abundant wildlife.

Quick Summary

MLS Number 21632214
Price $635,000
Lot Size 3.01 Acres
Bedrooms 3
Bathrooms 3 Full
Basement No
School District Twin Lakes
Status Sold
Year Built 1940
Garages Yes
Fireplaces 3
List Date 04/12/2019
Township Liberty
Subdivision ISLE OF HOMES

Property Map


Take E Shafer Drive north towards Buffalo. Turn left onto E Lake Road 10 E. Turn right onto Wenz Drive. Home is located at the end of Wenz.

What's the Payment?

Loan Amount* ($):

Loan Rate* (%):

Loan Term* (Years):

Home Value* ($)

Annual Taxes* ($):

Annual Insurance* ($):

Annual PMI* (%):


Projected Amounts:

Contact Us!

Nathan Pfahler

Nathan Pfahler

Phone: (317) 352-5994
Mobile: (317) 450-1094
Email Adress: npfahler@gmail.com

Listing provided courtesy of Encore Sotheby's International

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Ā© 2021 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORSĀ®